This is long overdue and I apologize for the delay in posting chapter 3, but events have spiraled out of control since my mother was injured by a third party and the insurance companies are jacking her around. Most of my free time has been spent assisting her and her quest for justice.
Chapter 3 is a really great chapter that explains why Dr. Phil should not be on the air and providing “advice” to anyone. I will eventually post the first 5 chapters (out of 19) in the book. Link to the book on Amazon: http://www.amazon.com/Get-Real-Dr-Phil-Discrediting/dp/1492324531/
Cancer survivors are likely going to disagree with my belief that one cannot simultaneously be both a victim and a survivor, but people who have read my thoughts below believe that I am correct with my belief.
CHAPTER 3
WHY DOES DR. PHIL ENCOURAGE VICTIMISM?
Dr. Phil believes that by probing past abuse and hanging onto that abuse and pain is the key to winning a person’s heart. I remember a show of his where a woman with four kids was afraid to touch her children because she thought that touching them was the same as molesting them. She had been “touched” when she was younger, by whom we were never told, but clearly her molestation experience affected her ability to be a mother to her children. Her kids were completely out of control from lack of human contact and discipline.
Dr. Phil pandered to her, telling her she was a victim and a survivor. She was crying and nodding, acknowledging she was in fact a victim, but had endured it and is now a survivor.
Bullshit.
Being a victim is surviving a Nazi concentration camp. Being a victim is having third-degree burns over most of your body because of an arsonist. Being a victim is convicted of a crime never committed and surviving prison only to see your reputation forever ruined because you’re now known only as a felon. Being a victim is having an abusive spouse who also abuses your children and a court won’t step in to help because the abuser is a convincing liar to authorities. Being a victim is working all your life, saving for retirement, and having a Wall Street banker gamble your entire savings away without facing any penalty because he works for a bank that’s “too big to fail.”
Being molested and not being able to move on is being an idiot. Here’s an interesting fact: A neighbor molested me when I was six years old. Am I crying about it? Am I wallowing in fear and seeking pity because someone touched me when I was very young? No, I am not.
I’ve accepted it, and have moved on. I haven’t forgotten, but I have forgiven. The event stays in my past, where it belongs. For me to continue to relive it and mentally travel back to the crime to “understand” what happened to me is to embrace victimism and I don’t want to be a victim. It happened, the person who did it was sick, and that’s life. Move on. Worse things have happened to other people, and they’ve been able to move on. It’s not as though I was strapped to a chair and had my fingernails pulled out with pliers. That would be something worth crying about twenty years later, but someone touching my privates for her own sick enjoyment isn’t worth reliving day and night.
If Dr. Phil wanted to impart his wisdom to that woman on his television show with the four out-of-control kids and correct her life and lifestyle, he would have told her to stop thinking like a victim and take back control in her life. Victims don’t have control; those who molest, rape, rob, beat, deny, and steal from the victim hold all the power, but only if we let them. So why would anyone who has been victimized want to continue to feel and think like a victim?
Dr. Phil should have taken that woman by the shoulders, and shaken her until her head flopped around like a rag doll, and said:
“You are NOT a victim, do you understand? What happened in the past stays in the past, where it belongs. Forgive and move on. The only way to move beyond the person who did this to you is to STOP believing you are still a victim, and be strong in that you are going to proceed through life as a liberated adult. You can’t drive a car forward if you’re looking in the rearview mirror, and looking forward is looking toward the future. Looking backward is reliving the past.”
Dr. Phil’s “get real” talk is as phony as a three-dollar-bill when he talks to victims of past abuse and codifies them into believing they are still helpless victims.
A survivor is someone who has been victimized and has been able to forgive and move forward. A victim is someone who is stuck in the past, to relive the past and never move forward.
One cannot simultaneously be both a victim and a survivor.
Relationship problems and abusive relationships are no different from past physical or sexual trauma. If a woman is in an abusive relationship and seeks competent professional help, would she be told that she’s a victim and a survivor, and to stay in the relationship? Of course not! She would be told that she’s being victimized, and that if she wants to have a normal life and relationship then she must get out of the abusive relationship. When she severs the cord to the past is when she stops being a victim and becomes a survivor. She’s no longer living in or looking at the past; her focus is on the future.
At that point, victimism has been replaced with survivorship, and we can proceed with our lives when we become a survivor. We cannot move forward when we perceive ourselves to be victims, and the point of life is to move forward.
This is basic common sense and this is getting real with real-life problems. Living in Dr. Phil’s fantasy world is the farthest thing from what victims should be told if they expect to have any type of normalcy in their lives.
Common sense does not require a college degree, but it’s becoming a rare commodity when people like Dr. Phil are poisoning minds with victimism. However, Dr. Phil isn’t the only one – the United States has become a country of victims, where we all expect to be rewarded for difficult times in the past, to be coddled and told it’s going to be okay. Gone are the days when children had to compete against each other for prizes and trophies. Today, your kid shows up for soccer practice and is handed a medal. He or she runs the hundred-yard-dash and comes in dead last and receives a good sportsmanship trophy. The United States calls itself the greatest country on Earth, while creating wimps who think like victims.
There are winners and losers in life, and winning doesn’t “just happen.” Winning takes hard work, skill, and determination, but anyone can be a loser, especially if he or she doesn’t put forth any effort. Rewarding people who lose or who put no effort into something sounds like communism, where everyone is equal and no matter what one accomplishes, all are treated the same. Victimism rewards losers and puts them on the same plane of existence as winners when the two are not even in the same hemisphere.
News flash: Just because you get the short end of the stick now and then doesn’t make you a loser. It’s called life, and you’re supposed to be able to figure out for yourself that putting pain and loss behind you is the key to moving on and experiencing success. Many years ago I remember reading the difference between a winner and a loser. “Winners listen; losers wait for their turn to talk.” That axiom for today should be: “Winners accept and forgive, thereby overcoming the obstacles that stand in their path. Losers whine about pain and seek pity.”
If you want to be a victim, nothing is going to stop you from believing it. But to be told you’re a victim, and to have victimism reinforced and to believe it, is a disservice to the victim.
Metaphorically, a victim would fall off a horse, wait for help, ask for a shoulder to cry on, relive the pain of falling off, tell others of the horrible experience, never come near a horse again, and be very afraid.
A survivor would fall off a horse, dust him or herself off, and climb back on. The horse isn’t going to get the better of the rider – not a chance.
You have to ask yourself, which are you? Victim or survivor? More importantly, which do you want to be? Shockingly, Dr. Phil wants people to be both, but both are yin and yang; oil and water. They are not compatible because they are opposites.
Only you can decide whether to be a victim or a survivor. Consider the related concepts for each word:
Victim:
Pessimism
Negativity
Betrayal
Hopelessness
Target
Loser
Suffer
Death
Survivor:
Optimism
Positivity
Enlightenment
Trust
Winner
Endure
Persevere
Life
One cannot be both a victim and a survivor at the same time, as Dr. Phil believes.
Example: According to Dr. Phil’s advice, the woman with the four out-of-control children who was once molested is a victim and is now a survivor. Both are present tense, which is not possible. From the examples listed above, can one be both dead and alive concurrently? Can it be light and dark at the same time? Noon and midnight in the same place? Figuratively, yes. Realistically, no. Can one be pessimistic and optimistic at the same time about the same thing? Impossible. So how can someone be both a victim and a survivor at the same time?
A survivor can believe she was a victim and is now a survivor. “Was” a victim is past tense; “is now” a survivor is present tense. That’s the correct thinking if one wishes to move forward. Dr. Phil’s advice is to live in both the past and present simultaneously, which cannot be accomplished. People listening to and taking this type of advice from Dr. Phil will be dissatisfied with the direction of their lives because such advice will leave them exactly where they began before reaching out for help.
The following is a true story and it happened to my good friend John, who is also a writing partner. It epitomizes victimism and survivorship, and the perception of both on the human mind.
In 1993 he was a young man, and on Sunday, March 28, at 5:45 a.m. he was on his way to a friend’s house to help him with his Sunday morning paper-route. Unknown to John, in close proximity to him was a nineteen-year-old man who was just waking up from a drunken stupor after a night of heavy partying and drinking with friends.
The nineteen-year-old drunk driver climbed into his truck, a Ford-150 XLT pickup truck that had been jacked up for off-road fun, and started off down the road toward his home. John happened to be a little ways in front of him, driving his Geo Storm, which we would classify as a subcompact car today. As John was stopped at a red light at what was normally a busy intersection but was deserted at that time of the morning, the drunken teenager was passing out at the wheel with a blood alcohol content of .145, with his foot still on the accelerator.
The next thing John knew, he was looking at an empty field. He was still seated in his car, but his glasses were not on his face; they turned out to be in the passenger footwell. When a Ford-150 XLT pickup truck, traveling at approximately 55 mph, hits a car from behind that is standing still, some very bad things happen to the person in the car. Not only were John’s glasses destroyed, but he also suffered a concussion (knocked unconscious for thirteen minutes), a hairline fracture of his skull, whiplash, a strained and sprained neck, a strained and sprained back, a broken tailbone, and a broken right foot.
Had he not been wearing his seat belt, the state patrol later remarked that John would have been killed instantly by decapitation. It was also lucky the truck had been jacked up because such a collision by a truck lower to the ground sometimes results in a ruptured gas tank and a fire, meaning John, having survived the collision but being unconscious, could have burned to death.
What happened to the drunk driver? Nothing. And by “nothing,” I mean physically or legally nothing. His parents were quite wealthy and literally bought his way out of trouble. He never even spent a night in jail, thanks to deferred prosecution. Deferred prosecution is a free pass when one has money and commits a crime. “Too big to fail” banks that commit serious felonies receive deferred prosecution from the United States Department of Justice, meaning the criminals are free to commit the same crimes over and over without consequence. The teenage drunk driver’s license was suspended for six months, and upon the successful completion of Alcoholics Anonymous counseling, his driver’s license was reinstated and his record wiped clean. No one would ever know he almost killed another person while driving drunk as a teenager.
John was not so lucky. He required the Jaws of Life to extract his unconscious body from his vehicle, and when he reached the hospital, the attending emergency room doctor, who was about to go off duty after having worked for twenty-four hours, got John mixed up with the reports of a fender-bender that occurred across town at the same time. He was taken for X-rays (which were misread), given a neck collar, and told to go home.
The next day, after the shock had worn off and the real pain had set in, John returned to the hospital in agony. The hospital, realizing it had made several mistakes the previous day but fearing a malpractice lawsuit, simply told him that the diagnosis made in the emergency room was correct and refused to treat his injuries. His insurance company, basing its opinion solely on the ER report, refused to pay for him to see orthopedists and specialists to treat his serious injuries. By the time he could raise the funds on his own to pay doctors who might be able to help him, his injuries had set and were permanent.
While he was in writhing pain and frantically seeking doctors who would accept delayed payment, the drunk driver’s insurance company, Safeco Insurance, called him every day to settle for his wrecked car and eventually John, without attorney representation at the time, received a check for $1,000 as compensation for his totaled vehicle. If he’d had an attorney, he would have received enough compensation to purchase a new vehicle, but insurance companies don’t make money for their shareholders by paying people what they are entitled.
One personal injury attorney after another told him his case wasn’t worth much because his medical records, diagnoses and injuries were in conflict, but when John located a real attorney (“real” meaning one who will fight for a client), he did receive a small settlement in 1995. Not that the money did him any good by then. He was fired from his job because it was physical labor and his injuries precluded any possibility of physical labor again, and it also cost him his active extrovert lifestyle. He was in constant pain and told me he seriously considered suicide when he developed migraine headaches (stemming from the head injury) that would last up to six weeks without relief. He was depressed, felt hopeless, had a negative outlook on life, and was almost homicidally enraged at the drunk driver and the system that had betrayed him.
That’s a victim.
The question is, would he choose to stay a victim?
One day in late 1995, John was more angry than usual and told me he was literally in a blind rage. He was so angry at the world that he wanted to destroy it. He kept two handguns in his bedroom, and said he walked very fast into his room, not sure of his intentions. He got about five feet in when he said he hit an invisible wall – it was like walking face-first into a brick wall, is how he described it. He stumbled backward, his shoulders relaxed, he took a deep breath, and said out loud, “I forgive him.”
Stunned at what had just happened, he said he shook his head as if to clear it, and then mentally asked himself if he did, in fact, forgive the drunk driver who had nearly killed him. He said the driver’s name out loud. There was no anger, no resentment, no hate.
John let his victimism go: He went from thinking like a victim to becoming a survivor.
He doesn’t know if it was the hand of God or the face of reason he walked into in his bedroom, but whatever it was, he released victimism and embraced survivorship.
Since that cathartic awakening, John is one of the most optimistic people I’ve ever known. The odds don’t matter to him; he will prevail through positive thinking and positive actions. The injuries he suffered in that 1993 car accident never improved; they’ve only worsened. He has an autoimmune disease that has resulted in a form of arthritis affecting all his major joints and can usually be seen limping and in obvious pain. He cannot stand for more than thirty minutes or sit for more than an hour before pain relief is necessary. Some days he cannot walk at all due to pain. He’s developed ankylosing spondylitis in his lower back that will eventually fuse his lower spine, and has been considered by every doctor he has seen to be totally physically disabled since 2001. Despite medical records more than a foot high, the Social Security Administration refuses to grant him disability benefits, stating he has no disabilities whatsoever. Sometimes being a white American male has its disadvantages.
A victim would get angry, depressed, and despondent. A victim would appear on Dr. Phil’s show and be told he’s a victim and learn to whine about it.
A survivor would take a deep breath and find a way to move on. John continues to move on, his head held high, a smile on his face, and bringing optimism to those he meets.
Can John be both a victim and a survivor at the same time, as Dr. Phil believes is possible and as Dr. Phil preaches? No, he cannot.
We cannot be victims and survivors at the same time. We must choose which we would like to be, and the way to graduate from being a victim to becoming a survivor is forgiveness. We must forgive those or that which has done us harm, or we cannot move forward. If you are a victim and you would like to forgive, you must mean it – you can’t just say to yourself, “I forgive him or her who has done this or that to me,” and expect to be released from your pain and suffering. True forgiveness comes from within.
This is a process that can take a long time to achieve. If you have been bitter and would like to experience the satisfaction that comes from absolution, think of it this way: Imagine changing your political affiliation in a day. If you’re a Republican, you’re now a die-hard Democrat. If you’re a Democrat, you’re now a traditional Republican. If you’re an Independent, I don’t know – now you’ve regressed and you’re one of “them.” It’s unthinkable, isn’t it? Yet it’s the same process for someone who will not forgive and let go: it requires a complete reversal in the way one thinks, believes and behaves. The process of change is not to be taken lightly. It requires motivation and commitment, because that change is going to stay with you for the rest of your life, and you will be a better person because of it.
Many people believe in God and understand that to be forgiven from a sin they must ask for forgiveness and truly mean it for the sin to be forgiven. I know many very arrogant people who call themselves Christians, who steal from others and treat people with disdain, yet each week they’ll attend church, ask for forgiveness, refuse to change their ways and believe in all sincerity they’re going to Heaven when they die. But Christianity teaches us we must truly forgive and change sinful ways, or moving on is not possible. It’s just lip service if we continue to abuse and inflict pain and misery on others. I don’t see how we can expect to be forgiven and receive enlightenment upon death if we will not change our evil ways here on Earth.
Dr. Phil does not seem to understand the concept of forgiveness. If he did, he would not encourage people to think of themselves simultaneously as both victims and survivors.
Regardless of what Dr. Phil believes and what he tells his audience, you were a victim and you are a survivor, or you are still a victim.
Is anyone else watching less YouTube?
Last year, I relied on YouTube for a good portion of my entertainment, mainly because I refuse to watch TV. Not only do I dislike the messages of fear, disinformation, and “hate thy neighbor” from television, but the relentless commercialism is so mind-numbingly repetitive that I feel as though I may go crazy after just an hour of watching TV.
I do not need to work at jobs I hate to buy shit I don’t need, just to keep pace with my neighbor!
YouTube was the salvation for those of us seeking to watch something entertaining without the constant bombardment of commercials and the messages of hate and fear.
No more.
Each time I try to watch YouTube, it feels like I’m back to watching TV: Buy this, read that, try this, watch that (to hate and fear, or is so stupid I’d need a lobotomy to sit through it), and that’s if I just want to listen to music by watching a video.
Watching a YouTube clip from a news broadcast is the same as watching 1970s Soviet-style disinformation.
Thanks VEVO, thanks YouTube — thank you very much for reinforcing the idea that if it needs to be watched it needs to be over-commercialized, so thank you for driving me away from YouTube because I don’t need that negativity in my life.
Leave a comment
Filed under Uncategorized
Tagged as commercialism, criticism, disinformation, fear, social commentary, VEVO, YouTube